Objects as Agents (Some Comments on O.L. Gubarev’s Response)
https://doi.org/10.26907/2541-7738.2023.4-5.103-112
Abstract
This article builds on the earlier discussion about the actor traits associated with North Germanic weapons. The historical theories and evidence used by O.L. Gubarev to support his approach are analyzed. It is argued that he seems to echo the historiographical tradition relying on oversimplified a priori assertions, rather than a comprehensive analysis of the concept of “living” things in certain cultures. In his polemical response, he misinterpreted some historical sources and the views of other researchers, while also presenting his own controversial ideas as undeniable facts. In conclusion, it is suggested that the beliefs in the ability of inanimate things to have person-like qualities and play an actual social role, the distinction between living and non-living nature, as well as the practice of attributing souls to non-living entities, should be regarded as separate problems that are not clearly related in all cultures.
Keywords
About the Author
D. V. Puzanov
Udmurt Institute of History, Language, and Literature, UdmFRC, Ural Branch, Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Izhevsk, 426004
References
1. Puzanov D.V. Were weapons of the Normans and Rus’ “alive”? Uchenye Zapiski Kazanskogo Universiteta. Seriya Gumanitarnye Nauki, 2021, vol. 163, no. 6, pp. 168–178. doi: 10.26907/2541-7738.2021.6.168-178. (In Russian)
2. Descola Ph. Po tu storonu prirody i kul’tury [Beyond Nature and Culture]. Moscow, NLO, 2012. 584 p. (In Russian)
3. Gubarev O.L. Further discussion on the oath of the Rus… (responding to D.V. Puzanov). Uchenye Zapiski Kazanskogo Universiteta. Seriya Gumanitarnye Nauki, 2023, vol. 165, no. 4-5, pp. …–... doi: 10.26907/2541-7738.2023.4-5…-... (In Russian)
4. Shchavelev A.S. Symbolic functions of the cross in Old Rus. In: Vostochnaya Evropa v drevnosti i srednevekov’e. Mnimye real’nosti v antichnoi i srednevekovoi istoriografii. XIV Chteniya pamyati chlen. korr. AN SSSR V.T. Pashuto. Moskva, 17–19 aprelya 2002 g. [Eastern Europe in Antiquity and the Middle Ages. Imaginary Realities in Ancient and Medieval Historiography. Proc. XIV Lectures in Memory of V.T. Pashuto, the Corresponding Member of the USSR Academy of Sciences. Moscow, April 17–19, 2002]. Moscow, 2002, pp. 248–254. (In Russian)
5. Fedotov G.P. Sobranie sochinenii [Collected Works]. Vol. 10: Russian religiosity. Part 1: The Christianity of Kievan Rus. 10th–13th Centuries. Moscow, Martis, SAM & SAM, 2001. 382 p. (In Russian)
6. Riisoy A.I. Performing oaths in eddic poetry: Viking Age fact or Medieval fiction? Journal of the North Atlantic, 2016, spec. vol. 8, pp. 141–156. https://doi.org/10.3721/037.002.sp811.
7. Sokolov M.V. Ocherki istorii psikhologicheskikh vozzrenii v Rossii v XI–XVII vekakh [Essays on the History of Psychological Views in Russia during the 11th–18th Centuries]. Moscow, Izd. Akad. Pedagog. Nauk RSFSR, 1963. 419 p. (In Russian)
8. Hedeager L. Iron Age Myth and Materiality. An Archaeology of Scandinavia AD 400–1000. London, New York, Routledge, 2011. xxx, 286 p.
9. Karavashkin A.V., Yurganov A.L. Region Doksa. Istochnikovedenie kul’tury [Doxa Region. Source Study of Culture]. Moscow, RGGU, 2005. 209 p. (In Russian)
10. Tolstaya S.M. Spell. In: Slavyanskie drevnosti [Slavic Antiquities]. Tolstoi N.I. (Ed.). Vol. 2: D–K (Kroshki). Moscow, Mezhdunar. Otnosheniya, 1999, pp. 258–260. (In Russian)
11. Commentaries. In: Smirnitskaya O.A. (Ed.) Islandskie sagi [Icelandic Sagas]. Vol. 2. St. Petersburg, Neva, Letnii Sad, 1999, pp. 537–558. (In Russian)
12. Svanidze A.A. Vikingi – lyudi sagi: zhizn’ i nravy [The Vikings: The People of Sagas. Their Life and Habits]. Moscow, NLO, 2014. 800 p. (In Russian)
13. Meletinskii E.M. “Edda” i rannie formy eposa [“Edda” and Early Epic Forms]. Moscow, Nauka, 1968. 364 p. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Puzanov D.V. Objects as Agents (Some Comments on O.L. Gubarev’s Response). Uchenye Zapiski Kazanskogo Universiteta Seriya Gumanitarnye Nauki. 2023;165(4-5):103-112. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.26907/2541-7738.2023.4-5.103-112
Views:
155
Email this article 