Development of the Culture of Dissertation Research in Archaeology in the Kazan Governorate and the TASSR during the 1910s–1940s

This article discusses the development of the culture of dissertation research in archaeology in the Kazan Governorate and the TASSR between the 1910s and 1940s. The central role in this process was played by A.P. Smirnov and N.F. Kalinin, two prominent archaeologists, as well as by V.F. Smolin and M.G. Khudyakov, their predecessors. A.P. Smirnov developed a research passion for studying the archaeology and history of the Volga Bulgaria in the early 1930s, and N.F. Kalinin became interested in exploring the primitive era during the second half of the 1940s. The large-scale excavations of the Suvar and Bolghar (since 1938) settlements offered a solid methodological background for A.P. Smirnov’s doctoral dissertation. In his work, he introduced a new approach to addressing a number of controversial issues, such as the dating of the emergence of the Bolghar settlement, by using archeological data. The outbreak of the war forced A.P. Smirnov to change his plans: he defended his dissertation in Moscow as early as 1944. N.F. Kalinin’s dissertation was based on the archaeological collections of the Neolithic, Bronze, and Early Iron Ages stored at the Kazan Museum; these were the well-known materials with a historiographical tradition. The problems of academic communication during the period before these two dissertations had been defended are addressed. The early stages of institutionalization of this process are analyzed. 

1. Vishlenkova E.A., Il’ina K.A. On academic degrees and how a dissertation in Russia gained scientific and practical importance. Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie, 2013, no. 4, pp. 84–107. (In Russian)

2. Vanyusheva K.V. Scientific communications in Russian provincial archaeology: From the late 19th century to the 1920s. Extended Abstract of Cand. Hist. Diss. Izhevsk, 2014. 28 р. (In Russian)

3. Zakharova E.Yu. The history of archaeology in the Central Black Earth region of Russia (from the last quarter of the 18th century to the 1970s). Extended Abstract of Doct. Hist. Diss. Voronezh, 2015. 39 p. (In Russian)

4. Rudenko K.A. Tatar ASSR’s history of writing and defending dissertations in archeology during the 1920s–1950s. Uchenye Zapiski Kazanskogo Universiteta. Seriya Gumanitarnye Nauki, 2022, vol. 164, no. 6, pp. 69–80. doi: 10.26907/2541-7738.2022.6.69-80. (In Russian)

5. Kruglikova I.T. On the occasion of the 100th anniversary of Boris Vladimirovich Farmakovskii’s birth. Sovetskaya Arkheologiya, 1970, no. 1, pp. 3–8. (In Russian)

6. Khabibullin A.A. Narody Srednego Povolzh’ya i Priural’ya: istoriya i kul’tura: [The Peoples of the Middle Volga and Urals: History and Culture]. Kazan, Meddok, 2008. 337 p. (In Russian)

7. Kuz’minykh S.V., Mikhailov E.P., Savenko S.N., Starostin P.N. Viktor Fedorovich Smolin: The main milestones of his life and work. Abashevskaya kul’turno-istoricheskaya obshchnost’: istoki, razvitie, nasledie: Matrialy mezhdunar. nauch. konf. [Abashevo Cultural and Historical Community: Origins, Development, and Heritage: Proc. Int. Sci. Conf.]. Kuz’mina O.V. (Ed.). Cheboksary, ChGIPN, 2003. pp. 35–46. (In Russian)

8. Smolin V.F. K voprosu o proiskhozhdenii narodnosti Kamsko-Volzhskikh bolgar (Razbor glavneishikh teorii) [On the Question of the Origin of the Kama-Volga Bulgarians (Analysis of the Main Theories)]. Kazan, Chuv. Otd. Gos. Izd., Kazan. Podotd., 1921. 56 p. (In Russian)

9. Kuz’minykh S.V. Viktor Fedorovich Smolin: 1890–1932 [Viktor Fedorovich Smolin: 1890–1932]. Kazan, Izd. Kazan. Univ., 2004. 32 p. (In Russian)

10. Zhebelev S.A. Academic degrees in the past, and the risk that they may be rejected in the future. In: Kamenetskii I.S., Formozov A.A. (Eds.) Ocherki istorii otechestvennoi arkheologii [Essays on the History of Archaeology in Russia]. Moscow, Nauka, 2002, no. 3, рр. 146–194. (In Russian)

11. Formozov A.A. Russkie arkheologi v period totalitarizma [Russian Archaeologists in the Period of Totalitarianism]. Moscow, Znak, 2004. 320 p. (In Russian)

12. Rudenko K.A. Gender aspects of Kazan archaeology in the second half of the 19th–20th centuries. Arkheologiya Evraziiskikh Stepei, 2021, no. 5, pp. 145–152. doi: 10.24852/25876112.202L5.145.152. (In Russian)

13. Tairov N.I. The first female Tatar archaeologist and bibliographer. Vestnik Kazanskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta Kul’tury i Iskusstv, 2017, no. 2, pp. 34–37. (In Russian)

14. Kuz’minykh S.V., Belozerova I.V. Institute of Archaeology and Art Studies of the Russian Association of Scientific Research Institutes of Social Sciences in the fates of national archaeology. Povolzhskaya Arkheologiya, 2018, no. 1, pp. 321–341. doi: 10.24852/pa2018.1.23.321.341. (In Russian)

15. Bryusov A.Ya. On the paths of archaeology. Rossiiskii Arkheologicheskii Ezhegodnik, 2012, no. 2, рр. 647–702. (In Russian)

16. Belozerova I.V., Demirova N.I. Materials on the history of Russian archaeology in the collection of the Department of Written Sources of the State Historical Museum. Arkheologiya Evraziiskikh Stepei, 2021, no. 5, pp. 14–28. doi: 10.24852/2587-6112.2021.5.14.28. (In Russian)

17. Spitsyn A.A. Priural’skii krai. Arkheologicheskie razyskaniya o drevneishikh obitatelyakh Vyatskoi gubernii [Archaeological Research on the Most Ancient Inhabitants of the Vyatka Governorate]. Moscow, Tip. E. Lissener i Yu. Roman, 1893. 189 p. (In Russian)

18. Smolin V.F. Archaeological essay on the Tatar Republiс. In: Ibragimov G.G., Vorob’ev N.I. (Eds.) Materialy po izucheniyu Tatarstana [Materials on the Study of Tatarstan]. Kazan, 2-ya Gostip. Komb. Izd. Pechati “Vostok”, 1925, no. 2: Dedicated to the fifth anniversary of Tatar S.S. Republic, pp. 5–70. (In Russian)

19. Ivanova M.G. A.P. Smirnov’s scientific legacy and modern problems of the study of medieval monuments of Udmurtia. Nauchnoe nasledie A.P. Smirnova i sovremennye problemy arkheologii Volgo-Kam’ya. Materialy nauch. konf. [A.P. Smirnov’s Scientific Legacy and Modern Problems of Archaeology in the Volga-Kama Region: Proc. Sci. Conf.]. Belotserkovskaya I.V. (Ed.). Moscow, GIM, 2000, pp. 177–183. (In Russian)

20. Ostanina T.I. Archaeological research by A.P. Smirnov in the territory of Udmurtia. In: Nauchnoe nasledie A.P. Smirnova i sovremennye problemy arkheologii Volgo-Kam’ya: Materialy nauch. konf. [A.P. Smirnov’s Scientific Legacy and Modern Problems of Archaeology in the Volga-Kama Region: Proc. Sci. Conf.]. Belotserkovskaya I.V. (Ed.). Moscow, GIM, 2000, pp. 22–26. (In Russian)

21. Kulikov K.I. Delo “SOFIN” [The SOFIN Case]. Izhevsk, UIIYaL, 1997. 338 p. (In Russian)

22. Mel’nikova O.M., Ostanina T.I. Archaeologist Alexey Petrovich Smirnov about the Great Patriotic War. Vestnik Udmurtskogo Universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya i Filologiya, 2020, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 718–727. doi: 10.35634/2412-9534-2020-30-4-718-727. (In Russian)

23. Rudenko K.A. Istoriya arkheologicheskogo izucheniya Volzhskoi Bulgarii (X – nachalo XIII v.). [A History of the Archaeological Study of the Volga Bulgaria (10th–Early 13th Centuries)]. Kazan, GBU “Resp. Tsentr Monit. Kach. Obraz.”, 2014. 768 p. (In Russian)

24. Egorov V.L. (Ed.). Izdaniya Gosudarstvennogo Istoricheskogo muzeya, 1873–1998: Bibliograficheskii ukazatel’ [Publications of the State Historical Museum, 1873–1998: A Bibliographic Index]. Moscow, GIM, 1999. 312 p. (In Russian)

25. Kuz’minykh S.V. M.G. Khudyakov: From the works unpublished during his lifetime. Arkheologiya Evraziiskikh Stepei, 2019, no. 2, pp. 292–305. (In Russian)

26. Khudyakov M.G. Vorobyevsky and Vichmarsky burial grounds. Izvestiya Obshchestva Arkheologii Istorii i Etnografii, 1929, vol. 34, nos. 3-4, pp. 72–82. (In Russian)

27. Pankratova E.G. F.V. Kiparisov, the last chairman of the State Academy of History of Material Culture (new materials for the biography). Vestnik Drevnei Istorii, 2020, vol. 80, no. 3, pp. 728–752. doi: 10.31857/S032103910008633-9. (In Russian)

28. Kuzminykh S.V. Kazan years in the life and career of M.G. Khudyakov. Kraevedcheskie chteniya, posvyashchennye 135-letiyu Obshchestva estestvoispytatelei pri KGU i 110-letiyu M.G. Khudyakova [Local History Lectures Dedicated to the 135th Anniversary of the Society of Naturalists at Kazan State University and the 110th Birthday of M.G. Khudyakov]. Mukhanov G.S. (Ed.). Kazan, Shkola, 2004. рр. 25–46. (In Russian) 29. Mukhamed’yarov F.Sh. Book review: A.P. Smirnov. Volga Bulgars. Moscow, GIM, 1951. 275 p. Proceedings of the State Historical Museum, no. XIX. Sovetskaya Arkheologiya, 1953, no. 17, pp. 260–273. (In Russian)

29. Marr N.Ya. Chuvashi-yafetidy na Volge [Chuvash Japhetites on the Volga River]. Cheboksary, Chuv. Gos. Izd., 1926. 74 p. (In Russian)

30. Akhmarov G.N. Excursions to the site of ancient Suvar. Izvestiya Obshchestva Arkheologii Istorii i Etnografii, 1893. vol. 11, no. 5, pp. 478–481. (In Russian)

31. Zorya R.S., Sitdikov A.G. N.F. Kalinin: Studying and preserving the historical and archaeological heritage of Bolghar fortified settlement. Arkheologiya Evraziiskikh Stepei, 2021, no. 2, pp. 346–360. doi: 10.24852/2587-6112.2021.2.346.360. (In Russian)

32. Khudyakov M.G. On the dating of the Bolghar buildings. In: Materialy po okhrane, remontu i restavratsii pamyatnikov TASSR [Materials for Preservation, Repair, and Restoration of the TASSR Monuments]. Kazan, Poligraf. Shk. im. A.V. Lunacharskogo, 1930, no. 4, pp. 36–48. (In Russian)

33. Klimov I.M. (Ed.) Materialy po istorii Tatarii [Materials on the History of Tataria]. Kazan, Tatknigoizdat, 1948, no. 1. 487 p. (In Russian)

34. Muzei bolgarskoi tsivilizatsii [Museum of Bulgarian Civilization]. Vol. 3: Discovery of the ancient Bolghar. Kazan, Glavdizain, 2016. 254 p. (In Russian)

35. Zorya R.S. “Please protect me, after all, from physical death...”: Adding new facts to the biography of N.F. Kalinin. Uchenye Zapiski Krymskogo Federal’nogo Universiteta imeni V.I. Vernadskogo.

36. Seriya “Istoricheskie nauki”, 2021, vol. 7, no. 2, рр. 66–80. doi: 10.37279/2413-1741-2021-7-266-8. (In Russian)

37. Krainov D.A. The State Historical Museum. Bor’ba Klassov, 1934, nos. 7–8, pp. 261–264. (In Russian)

38. Belyaev D. Mutual examination of museums. Sovetskii Muzei, 1937, no. 3, рр. 8–12. (In Russian)

39. Rudenko K.A. Archaeology in the TASSR during the second half of the 1930s–late 1940s. In: Gaidukov P.G., Tunkina I.V., Sorokina I.A. (Eds.) Ocherki istorii otechestvennoi arkheologii [Essays on the History of Russian Archaeology]. Moscow, IA Ross. Akad. Nauk, pp. 175–195. doi: 10.25681/IARAS.2022.978-5-94375-386-2.175-195. (In Russian)

40. Rudenko K.A. Kazanskie arkheologi v pervye gody posle Velikoi Otechestvennoi voiny (1945– 1949) (po materialam perepiski A.P. Smirnova i A.M. Efimovoi) [Kazan Archaeologists in the First Years after the Great Patriotic War (1945–1949) (Based on the Correspondence between A.P. Smirnov and A.M. Efimova)]. Kazan, Shkola, 2021. 476 p. (In Russian)

41. Shtukenberg A.A., Vysotskii N.F. Materials for the study of the Stone Age in the Kazan Governorate. Trudy Obshchestva Estestvoispytatelei pri Imperatorskom Kazanskom Universitete, 1885, vol. XIV, no. 5, pp. 3–14. (In Russian)

42. Krotov P.I. On new studies of the Stone Age in the Kazan Governorate (near the villages of Kokshaisk and St. Kokuzy). Izvestiya Obshchestva Arkheologii Istorii i Etnografii, 1905, vol. XXI, no. 3, pp. 259–262. (In Russian)

43. Vysotskii N.F. Traces of the Stone Age in the Kazan Governorate: Essays on prehistoric archaeology and anthropology of northeastern Russia. Izvestiya Severo-Vostochnogo Arkheologicheskogo i Etnograficheskogo Instituta v Kazani, 1920, vol. 1, pp. 25–36. (In Russian)

44. Gimadi Kh.G. (Ed.) Istoriya Tatarskoi ASSR [History of the Tatar ASSR]. Vol. 1: From ancient times to the Great October Socialist Revolution. Kazan, Tatknigoizdat, 1955. 552 p. (In Russian)

45. Mukhamed’yarov F.Sh. Book review: Materials on the History of Tataria. Issue 1. Kazan, Tatgosizdat, 1948. 487 p. Voprosy Isotrii, 1950, no. 4, pp. 143–146. (In Russian)